good italian restaurants in brooklyn

2 min read 11-01-2025

Brooklyn's Best Italian Eats: From Classic Red Sauce to Modern Takes

Brooklyn boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and its Italian restaurants are a major part of the borough's charm. Whether you're craving classic red sauce, innovative pasta dishes, or authentic Neapolitan pizza, you'll find it all here. This guide explores some of the best Italian restaurants Brooklyn has to offer, categorized for your convenience. This isn't an exhaustive list – Brooklyn's Italian food scene is vast and constantly evolving – but it's a great starting point for your next delicious adventure.

Classic Red Sauce Joints: A Taste of Tradition

These are the places where you'll find familiar favorites, done exceptionally well. Expect generous portions, family-style service, and a comforting atmosphere.

L&B Spumoni Gardens (Bensonhurst)

Why it's great: A Brooklyn institution, L&B is renowned for its Sicilian-style pizza. The thick, slightly sweet crust is a true standout. Their other dishes are equally satisfying. Don't forget to try the spumoni!
What to order: Sicilian pizza, lasagna, spumoni ice cream.

Gennaro's (Midwood)

Why it's great: A neighborhood gem serving up hearty, traditional Italian-American fare. Gennaro's has a loyal following for its delicious pasta dishes and generous portions.
What to order: Spaghetti with meat sauce, chicken parmesan, baked ziti.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria (DUMBO)

Why it's great: Located under the Brooklyn Bridge, Grimaldi's offers iconic coal-fired pizza. The thin crust, charred edges, and simple toppings are irresistible. Be prepared for a wait, as it's incredibly popular.
What to order: Cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, calzone.

Modern Italian: A Fusion of Flavors

Brooklyn also houses a thriving scene of restaurants that put a modern spin on classic Italian dishes. Expect creative ingredients, innovative techniques, and a sophisticated atmosphere.

Lilia (Williamsburg)

Why it's great: Lilia is a highly acclaimed restaurant known for its exceptional pasta dishes. The ingredients are fresh and seasonal, and the pasta is made in-house. Reservations are essential.
What to order: Handmade pasta dishes (the menu changes seasonally), roasted vegetables.

Via Carota (West Village - technically not Brooklyn, but close enough!)

Why it's great: Though technically in the West Village, its close proximity and incredible reputation warrant inclusion. Via Carota offers rustic Italian charm with a focus on simple, flavorful dishes.
What to order: Pasta dishes, seasonal salads, simple pizzas.

Paulie Gee's (Greenpoint)

Why it's great: Another amazing pizza spot, Paulie Gee's offers creative and unique pizza options. The crust is wonderfully chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.
What to order: Regina Margherita pizza, Hellboy pizza (spicy!), their seasonal specials.

Pizza Perfection: Beyond the Classics

Beyond the famous Grimaldi's, Brooklyn has a wealth of incredible pizzerias, each with its own unique style.

Emily (Clinton Hill)

Why it's great: Emily is known for its wood-fired pizzas with creative and delicious toppings. The crust is perfectly charred and has a nice chew.
What to order: The Emmy, the Calabrese, their seasonal specials.

Roberta's Pizza (Bushwick)

Why it's great: Roberta's is a Bushwick institution, famous for its creative pizzas and lively atmosphere. The outdoor seating is great in warmer months.
What to order: Bee Sting pizza, Cheeseburger pizza, their rotating seasonal pizzas.

Finding Your Perfect Italian Meal in Brooklyn

Whether you're seeking a nostalgic red sauce experience or a modern culinary adventure, Brooklyn's Italian restaurants have something for everyone. Remember to check websites for menus, hours, and reservations (highly recommended for popular spots!). This list is a starting point; explore the neighborhood and discover your own hidden gems. Buon appetito!